What does an insurance agency virtual assistant cost?
Agency owners in October 2025 and February 2026 reported human virtual assistant costs of about $30,000 a year through a VA agency, or $10,000–15,000 hired directly offshore. These are reported examples, not typical quotes. AI and automation help from Tyler Mayberry starts with a free 30-minute conversation; anything worth building is $125 an hour or a fixed quote, agreed before it starts.
Human staffing figures describe a year of reported staffing cost; Cirlet's scoped hourly or fixed work is not an annual replacement quote and differs in scope.
The comparison
| VA agency | Direct offshore VA | AI and automation (Cirlet) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost: owner-reported examples, October 2025 / February 2026, not typical quotes | about $30k a year | $10–15k a year | Free first conversation, then $125 an hour or a fixed quote |
| Is a person | Yes | Yes | No |
| Can be licensed, quote and advise | Sometimes | Rarely | No |
| Answers the phone | Often | Often | No |
| Prepares renewals, certificates and changes | Yes | Yes | Yes, for your staff to check |
| Training and turnover | Shared | Yours | No hiring; built around the tools you already use |
Compare one task from start to checked result
Compare your current process, a simple rule and an AI-assisted draft on the same small task. Define the checked result first. An unfinished draft and a checked worklist are different outputs.
Download the blank task-cost worksheet (CSV). It contains blank values for three methods, not a benchmark, quote, savings estimate or automatic calculator. No signup or customer records needed. Use fictional or otherwise authorized material; keep private details out of the sheet.
- Write the task and the required finished result in the notes. Use comparable input and count usable results for each method. Record failed attempts and exceptions too.
- Enter staff minutes for preparing input, running the task while attended, reviewing, correcting and filing the result. Count each minute once. Record elapsed minutes separately; an unattended wait is not staff time.
- Choose an internal hourly staff-cost assumption. Total staff minutes divided by 60, multiplied by that rate, gives staff cost per batch. Add the additional tool charge allocated to that batch. Record whether each value was observed or estimated; leave unknowns blank and explain them.
- Record one-time setup minutes and charges separately. For a monthly comparison, multiply comparable per-batch costs by the expected batch count, then add monthly upkeep staff cost (minutes divided by 60 times the same hourly rate) and recurring charges counted nowhere else. Add setup to the first month or disclose the period over which you spread it.
- Check output quality before comparing totals. Repeat another comparable batch and keep the corrections. A cheaper result that misses the required work does not pass.
Use the same currency and cost basis for all methods. Do not count a shared subscription in full against every task or count the same charge twice. Staff capacity released is not automatically money saved. Coverage decisions, approval and actual sending stay with responsible agency staff. This worksheet does not establish that a tool works with your agency system.
Fictional arithmetic example
For this illustration, assume each method produces the same ten checked results in one batch. The internal staff-cost assumption is $30 an hour. All minutes and charges below are invented to demonstrate the arithmetic; they are not observed timings, quotes or model results.
- Manual process: 120 total staff minutes ÷ 60 × $30 = $60 staff cost. With $0 additional tool cost, the batch costs $60, or $6 per checked result.
- Simple rule: 90 total staff minutes ÷ 60 × $30 = $45 staff cost. With $1 additional tool cost, the batch costs $46, or $4.60 per checked result.
- AI-assisted draft: 130 total staff minutes ÷ 60 × $30 = $65 staff cost. With $5 additional tool cost, the batch costs $70, or $7 per checked result.
Total staff minutes include preparation, attended running, review, correction and filing. A fast draft can still take more staff time to finish. These per-batch totals exclude setup and monthly upkeep; add those separately using the worksheet instructions before making a monthly comparison. Actual quality and costs must be checked in your own trial.
Work out one batch with your figures
Count only results your staff have checked against the required standard. Include preparation, attended running, review, corrections and filing in staff minutes. Use one currency throughout. Leave unknown values blank; enter zero only when you know the cost is zero.
This is arithmetic on your inputs, not a quality check, quote or savings forecast. Setup and monthly upkeep are excluded; add them separately with the worksheet before comparing periods. Repeat for each method using comparable checked results. Figures are calculated in this browser; this calculator does not send or save them.
Where the numbers come from
- Owner-reported examples, not typical quotes: VA agency about $30k a year, direct offshore $10–15k. an agency owner on r/InsuranceAgent, October 2025 and another, February 2026, comparing agency VAs with hiring directly.
- AI and automation: Cirlet's published prices, read 15 October 2026.
Cirlet's prices
- A first 30-minute conversation with Tyler is free, by phone or on a shared screen. Nothing to install and no customer records needed.
- Automation is $125 an hour or a fixed quote. The work and the price are agreed before anything starts, and it can use the tools your agency already has.
- Training and ongoing support are scoped separately when needed. Agree what is included before work starts; see Cirlet's current service prices.
Which to pick
If you need someone on the phones, hire a person. If the backlog is paperwork in EZLynx, carrier sites or email, first check the reports and workflows those tools already support. Try a permitted export or a fictional sample before connecting accounts. An AI-prepared draft does not establish a live connection or replace your licensed staff's review. Talk it through with Tyler before you decide.